BIPA Lawsuit Defense

What to Do When Your Business Is Sued Under Illinois' Biometric Privacy Law

 

If your business has been sued or received a demand letter under the Illinois Biometric Information Privacy Act, I provide BIPA lawsuit defense for online businesses and employers in the Circuit Court of Cook County and the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois. I'm Jonathan Francis, a Chicago attorney, and I defend companies against BIPA class action claims over virtual try-on tools, ID and selfie verification, voice features, and biometric timeclocks.

The first weeks matter. Whether the case stays in state court or moves to federal court, whether an arbitration clause applies, and whether your insurer has to defend are all decided early, and the 2024 amendment and a 2026 federal appeals decision have changed how damages are counted.

This page is general information, not legal advice about your situation.

Free, confidential review. Tell me who sued or wrote to you and which feature or tool is involved. I'll tell you what you're facing and the first deadlines.

Contacting me does not create an attorney-client relationship. Until we've confirmed there's no conflict and agreed in writing to work together, please send only your business name and a short description of what you need, and don't include other confidential details.

What is a BIPA lawsuit?

A BIPA lawsuit is a claim, usually filed on behalf of a proposed class, that a business collected, stored, shared, or failed to destroy a person's face geometry, fingerprint, voiceprint, or other biometric identifier without following 740 ILCS 14/15.

Complaints typically allege that the business had no public retention policy (section 15(a)), collected data without written notice and a release (15(b)), or shared it with a vendor without consent (15(d)) (740 ILCS 14/15). The plaintiff does not have to prove any actual harm; being "aggrieved" by the violation is enough (Rosenbach v. Six Flags, 2019 IL 123186).

BIPA demand letters. Some plaintiffs' firms send a letter before suing, often with a draft complaint and an offer to resolve one person's claim. A letter is an opportunity: you can investigate, notify your insurer, and fix the consent flow before anything is filed. Treat its deadline as real, and don't respond without advice, because what you say can become evidence of willfulness.

BIPA damages per violation after the amendment

BIPA allows $1,000 per negligent violation and $5,000 per intentional or reckless violation (or actual damages if higher), plus attorney's fees, and since August 2, 2024, repeated collection from the same person by the same method counts as one violation.

Negligent

The greater of $1,000 or actual damages for each violation (740 ILCS 14/20).

Intentional or reckless

The greater of $5,000 or actual damages for each violation, plus fees, costs, and an injunction.

Per person, not per scan

Same person, same method: "at most, one recovery" under 15(b); same recipient: one recovery under 15(d) (Public Act 103-0769).

Before the amendment, the Illinois Supreme Court held that every unconsented scan was a separate violation, while noting that damages under the Act appear to be discretionary rather than mandatory (Cothron v. White Castle, 2023 IL 128004, ¶ 42). On April 1, 2026, the Seventh Circuit held that the amendment is remedial and applies to cases already pending when it took effect (Clay v. Union Pacific R.R. Co., 171 F.4th 975 (7th Cir. 2026), consolidated with Willis v. Universal Intermodal Services, Inc., No. 25-2761, and Gregg v. Central Transport LLC, No. 25-2762). That binds federal courts in Illinois. Illinois state courts are not bound, and as of October 2026 no Illinois appellate court had ruled, so in Cook County the per-scan argument may still be raised for pre-amendment conduct.

Even per person, the math is serious: a class of 10,000 Illinois users at $1,000 each is $10 million before fees. That is why the defenses below, and the discretion courts have over the award, matter so much.

BIPA statute of limitations

Every BIPA claim is subject to Illinois' five-year catchall limitations period, so conduct going back five years before the complaint can be at issue.

The Illinois Supreme Court rejected a one-year period for some subsections and applied five years to all of them (Tims v. Black Horse Carriers, 2023 IL 127801). When a particular person's claim accrued, and whether class members' claims are timely, are still worth testing, especially for a feature you changed or retired years ago.

Common defenses in BIPA class action defense

The strongest BIPA defenses usually come from the technology and the paperwork: where the conduct happened, whether the tool actually captured a biometric identifier, whether an exemption applies, and whether the person consented or agreed to arbitrate.

  • Extraterritoriality. BIPA reaches only conduct that occurred primarily and substantially in Illinois. In May 2026 the Third Circuit affirmed judgment for a company whose relevant activity took place in Virginia with no Illinois interaction (McGoveran v. Amazon Web Services, Inc., No. 24-3215 (3d Cir. May 12, 2026)). For an out-of-state online business, this and personal jurisdiction are early questions.
  • Not a biometric identifier. Photographs are excluded by statute, and some courts have held that face data that cannot identify a person is not biometric information (for example, Zellmer v. Meta Platforms, Inc., No. 22-16925 (9th Cir. June 17, 2024)). How your vendor's tool works, and whether data ever left the user's device, matters.
  • Health care exclusion. Information collected for health care treatment, payment, or operations under HIPAA is excluded, and that reaches data from employees as well as patients (Mosby v. Ingalls Memorial Hospital, 2023 IL 129081). Some federal courts in Illinois dismissed eyewear try-on suits on this ground, but an Illinois appellate court held the exclusion does not cover non-prescription eyewear (Marino v. Gunnar Optiks, LLC, 2024 IL App (1st) 231826), and the Seventh Circuit has said a virtual try-on "seems to be aesthetic, not medical" (Clements v. Gunnar Optiks, LLC, No. 25-1890 (7th Cir. July 10, 2026)).
  • Financial institutions. BIPA does not apply to financial institutions subject to Title V of the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act, and the Third Circuit applied that to a vendor authenticating callers for a financial company (740 ILCS 14/25(c); McGoveran).
  • Government contractors. The Act does not apply to a contractor, subcontractor, or agent of a state agency or local government when working for that government body (§ 25(e)).
  • Consent. A written release, an employee release signed as a condition of employment, or, since August 2, 2024, an electronic signature defeats a 15(b) claim if it says what the statute requires.
  • Arbitration. An arbitration clause and class waiver in your website or app terms can move the case out of court, but only if the user actually agreed to those terms and they cover the feature. Mass arbitration is its own risk to plan for.
  • Standing in federal court. The Seventh Circuit held that a 15(b) consent claim supports federal standing, but the general duty to publish a policy under 15(a) does not (Bryant v. Compass Group USA, Inc., 958 F.3d 617 (7th Cir. 2020)), and plaintiffs can plead around federal jurisdiction to stay in state court (Thornley v. Clearview AI, Inc., 984 F.3d 1241 (7th Cir. 2021)). Where the case is heard is often the first fight.

Will insurance cover a BIPA lawsuit?

Insurance may cover a BIPA lawsuit, because the Illinois Supreme Court held that a general liability policy's personal and advertising injury coverage required the insurer to defend one, but many later policies add exclusions that courts have enforced.

In West Bend Mutual Insurance Co. v. Krishna Schaumburg Tan, Inc., 2021 IL 125978, sharing fingerprint data with a single vendor was a "publication" that potentially violated a right of privacy, and the policy's violation-of-statutes exclusion did not apply. Since then, courts have split. An Illinois appellate court enforced a broader catch-all exclusion (National Fire Insurance Co. v. Visual Pak Co., 2023 IL App (1st) 221160), while the Seventh Circuit has read similar statutory exclusions narrowly but enforced "access or disclosure of confidential or personal information" exclusions (Thermoflex Waukegan, LLC v. Mitsui Sumitomo Insurance USA, Inc., 102 F.4th 438 (7th Cir. 2024)). Tender to every carrier, including general liability, cyber, employment practices, and umbrella, and for every policy year in the five-year window.

What to do this week

Calendar your response deadline, notify every insurer in writing, preserve the tool's data and records, and don't change or delete anything, or contact the plaintiff, until someone has reviewed the claim.

  1. Find the deadline. In an Illinois circuit court, the appearance and answer are generally due within 30 days after service. In federal court it is generally 21 days. A defendant that wants to remove a state case to federal court generally has 30 days from service.
  2. Notify your insurers. Send written notice to each carrier for each policy year that could apply, even if you expect an exclusion.
  3. Preserve evidence. Issue a litigation hold. Don't delete biometric data, logs, or old versions of the feature without advice; the destruction duty and the duty to preserve evidence have to be balanced.
  4. Pull the paperwork. Consent screens and their dates, privacy and retention policy versions, website or app terms and how users accepted them, employee releases, and every vendor contract.
  5. Tender to your vendor. If a vendor runs the tool, check the contract for indemnity and send a written tender.
  6. Stay quiet publicly. Don't contact the plaintiff, post about the case, or change your public policies without thinking through how it will look as evidence.

The response deadline runs from service. Start your free review now and you'll hear back promptly.

Contacting me does not create an attorney-client relationship. Until we've confirmed there's no conflict and agreed in writing to work together, please send only your business name and a short description of what you need, and don't include other confidential details.

Virtual try-on lawsuits in Illinois

Virtual try-on lawsuits claim that a website or app tool that maps a shopper's face to preview eyewear, makeup, or jewelry captured face geometry without BIPA notice, a release, or a public retention policy.

The results have gone both ways. Federal courts in Illinois at first dismissed eyewear try-on suits under the health care exclusion (Svoboda v. Frames for America (N.D. Ill. Sept. 8, 2022); Warmack-Stillwell v. Christian Dior, No. 22-cv-4633 (N.D. Ill. Feb. 10, 2023)), while a federal court in New York let a 15(b) claim against an out-of-state brand proceed because Illinois residents used the tool from Illinois (Theriot v. Louis Vuitton North America, No. 22-cv-2944 (S.D.N.Y. 2022)). More recent appellate decisions cut against the health care defense: an Illinois appellate court held it does not reach non-prescription eyewear (Marino), and the Seventh Circuit vacated a dismissal, calling the try-on tool apparently "aesthetic, not medical" (Clements). Cosmetics and fashion tools cannot rely on the health care argument, so the defense there usually turns on what the tool actually captured, where, and who held it.

Where BIPA cases are filed

BIPA cases are commonly filed in the Circuit Court of Cook County or the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois, and which court hears the case is often contested through removal and remand.

The Act lets a plaintiff sue in an Illinois circuit court or bring the claim as a supplemental claim in federal court. Class actions are often removed under the Class Action Fairness Act, and the 2026 per-person ruling can change the amount-in-controversy math; the Seventh Circuit noted that district courts may need to revisit jurisdiction on remand. Cases also appear in other Illinois circuit courts and in federal courts in other states. In federal courts outside Illinois, I work with local counsel or seek admission for the case (pro hac vice).

How I handle BIPA lawsuit defense

I defend online businesses and employers against BIPA demand letters and class actions, starting with the deadline, insurance tender, and an early read on forum, arbitration, and exemptions.

I review the complaint or letter, the feature and how its vendor processes data, your terms, and your policies, then lay out the options: an early motion, a motion to compel arbitration, removal, an individual resolution, or a defense through class certification. I also fix the consent flow and retention policy going forward, because ongoing collection keeps exposure open. I'm admitted in Illinois and in the U.S. District Courts for the Northern and Central Districts of Illinois and the Eastern District of Wisconsin.

Related: BIPA compliance · Business and IP litigation · TCPA text message lawsuits · E-commerce law

Frequently asked questions

I was sued under BIPA. What happens if I ignore it?

The court can enter a default judgment, and in a statute with $1,000 to $5,000 in liquidated damages per violation plus attorney's fees, that can be very expensive to undo. In Illinois circuit court the appearance and answer are generally due within 30 days after service, and in federal court generally 21 days.

How much are BIPA damages per violation after the amendment?

The statute sets $1,000 per negligent violation and $5,000 per intentional or reckless violation, or actual damages if higher. Since August 2, 2024, repeated collection from the same person by the same method is one violation, and the Seventh Circuit has applied that to pending cases. Courts also have discretion over the award.

What is the statute of limitations for a BIPA claim?

Five years for every BIPA claim, under the Illinois Supreme Court's 2023 decision in Tims v. Black Horse Carriers. When each person's claim accrued is often contested, especially for features that changed over time.

My company is not in Illinois. Can I still be sued under BIPA?

Yes, if the collection occurred primarily and substantially in Illinois, for example when Illinois residents used your tool from Illinois. Where your servers, staff, and vendor processing are located, and whether an Illinois court has personal jurisdiction over you, are early defenses to evaluate.

Will my insurance cover a BIPA lawsuit?

Possibly. The Illinois Supreme Court held in 2021 that a general liability policy required the insurer to defend a BIPA suit, but many newer policies contain biometric or access-or-disclosure exclusions that courts have enforced. Notify every carrier in writing right away.

Can the arbitration clause in my website terms stop a BIPA class action?

It can, if the user clearly agreed to the terms and the clause covers use of the biometric feature. Courts look closely at how assent was obtained, so a browsewrap link in the footer is weaker than a required checkbox. Mass individual arbitrations carry their own costs.

I received a BIPA demand letter but no lawsuit. Should I respond?

Get it reviewed before you respond. A pre-suit letter gives you time to notify your insurer, check your consent records and vendor contracts, and fix the feature, and an early resolution may be possible. What you say in a response can be used later, so don't admit facts or explain your technology without advice.

About the author

Jonathan M. Francis, Attorney at Law. Admitted in Illinois. Registered patent attorney with the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office since 2014. Admitted to the U.S. District Courts for the Northern and Central Districts of Illinois and the Eastern District of Wisconsin. Member, Illinois State Bar Association Intellectual Property Law Section Council.

Jonathan defends online businesses and employers in privacy, IP, and commercial disputes in the Circuit Court of Cook County and federal court, and advises them on biometric privacy compliance. J.D., DePaul University College of Law (Certificate in Intellectual Property Law).

Law Office of Jonathan Francis · 3525 West Peterson Avenue, Suite 604, Chicago, Illinois 60659 · Francis@jfrancislaw.com · (312) 834-4170

Last updated: October 2026

Attorney Advertising. General information, not legal advice. Contacting this office does not create an attorney-client relationship. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Responsible attorney: Jonathan M. Francis, 3525 West Peterson Avenue, Suite 604, Chicago, Illinois 60659.