If your business received a demand letter or was sued over marketing texts, a TCPA text message lawsuit usually turns on your consent records, the timing of the messages, and which court you're in. I'm Jonathan Francis, an Illinois-based attorney advising online businesses that sell nationwide, and I defend e-commerce brands and other businesses against TCPA and state telemarketing claims over text messages.
These claims often start as a letter from a plaintiff's firm asking for payment for an individual customer, with a class action as the stated alternative. What you do in the first week, especially with your platform data, shapes everything after.
This page is general information, not legal advice about your situation.
Free, confidential review. Tell me who sent the letter or filed the case and when you received it. I'll tell you what you're facing and what to preserve right away.
Contacting me does not create an attorney-client relationship. Until we've confirmed there's no conflict and agreed in writing to work together, please send only your business name and a short description of what you need, and don't include other confidential details.
What is a TCPA text message lawsuit?
A TCPA text message lawsuit is a claim under the federal Telephone Consumer Protection Act, often joined with a state law claim, alleging that a business sent marketing texts without the required consent, to a number on the Do Not Call Registry, or outside permitted hours.
The most common theories against online brands are:
No written consent
The texts were sent with automated technology without prior express written consent (47 U.S.C. § 227(b); 47 C.F.R. § 64.1200(a)(2), (f)(9)).
Do Not Call
More than one marketing text within any 12-month period to a residential number on the National Do Not Call Registry (§ 227(c)(5); § 64.1200(c)(2)).
Quiet hours
Marketing texts before 8 a.m. or after 9 p.m. in the recipient's local time (§ 64.1200(c)(1)), or outside a stricter state window.
Ignored opt-out
Texts kept coming after the person replied STOP or otherwise asked them to end.
State law
Florida's Telephone Solicitation Act, Oklahoma's similar law, Texas's telephone solicitation law (which covers texts since September 2025), and others.
What the plaintiff can claim
The TCPA allows $500 per text, and up to $1,500 per text if the court finds the violation willful or knowing, plus an injunction; state laws add their own per-message damages.
- Autodialer and consent claims: actual damages or $500 per violation, whichever is greater, up to triple for willful or knowing violations (§ 227(b)(3)).
- Do Not Call and quiet-hours claims: up to $500 per violation, up to triple if willful or knowing, but only for someone who received more than one call within 12 months, and the business has a defense if it had reasonable practices and procedures in place (§ 227(c)(5)).
- Florida: actual damages or $500 per violation, up to triple for willful or knowing violations (Fla. Stat. § 501.059(10)).
- Texas: since SB 140, consumers can sue under the Deceptive Trade Practices Act over texts to numbers on the state no-call list and texts sent without a required registration.
The TCPA does not award the plaintiff attorney's fees, which is one reason plaintiffs' firms bring these cases as class actions: the per-message amounts are multiplied across everyone who received the same campaign. That is also why the size of the potential class, not the individual claim, usually drives the defense.
Common defenses to TCPA text claims
The strongest defenses usually come from your own platform data: proof that the person consented, when and where the texts were received, and whether the number really belonged to the plaintiff.
- Consent records. An opt-in timestamp, the form or keyword used, and the disclosure shown at the time often end the case. Even where a signed writing is missing, consent can defeat a quiet-hours claim: in King v. Bon Charge, No. 25-cv-00105 (D. Del. Apr. 30, 2026), the court dismissed a quiet-hours claim because the plaintiff had texted a keyword to sign up.
- The autodialer definition. After Facebook, Inc. v. Duguid, 592 U.S. 395 (2021), equipment is an autodialer only if it uses a random or sequential number generator. Platforms that text a stored list of subscribers often fall outside that definition, though Florida's statute uses its own test.
- Texts may not be "calls" for Do Not Call claims. In Steidinger v. Blackstone Medical Services, No. 25-2398 (7th Cir. July 14, 2026), the Seventh Circuit held that texts are not "telephone calls" under § 227(c)(5), ending private Do Not Call claims over texts in federal courts in Illinois, Indiana, and Wisconsin. Quiet-hours claims rest on the same provision, so defendants argue the reasoning reaches them too, though no appeals court has said so. Courts outside the Seventh Circuit are split, and no other federal court of appeals has decided the question.
- Residential subscriber. The Do Not Call and quiet-hours rules protect "residential telephone subscribers." A number used for business, or registered by someone other than the plaintiff, can fall outside the rule.
- Time zone and location. Quiet hours are measured at the called party's location, not by area code. A plaintiff with an East Coast area code who lives in another time zone, or who was traveling, may not have received the text during quiet hours at all.
- Reassigned numbers. If the number belonged to a consenting customer and was later reassigned, the FCC's Reassigned Numbers Database offers a safe harbor against consent-based claims for senders who checked it before texting and got a "no" response (47 C.F.R. § 64.1200(m)).
- Florida's pre-suit STOP rule. For text claims under the FTSA, the recipient must first reply "STOP," and the sender then has 15 days to stop (§ 501.059(10)(c)). A plaintiff who skipped that step may not have a Florida claim.
- Standing and class issues. Courts disagree on how much harm a single text causes; the en banc Eleventh Circuit held one unwanted text is enough (Drazen v. Pinto, 74 F.4th 1336 (11th Cir. 2023) (en banc)). Differences in how class members signed up often matter more, because they can defeat class certification.
How McLaughlin v. McKesson changed TCPA defense
In June 2025 the Supreme Court held that federal district courts are not bound by the FCC's interpretations of the TCPA in private lawsuits, so a business can now argue that an FCC order reads the statute wrong.
Before McLaughlin Chiropractic Associates, Inc. v. McKesson Corp., 606 U.S. 146 (2025), many courts held that the Hobbs Act required them to follow FCC orders unless someone had challenged the order directly in a court of appeals. The Court held that district courts must decide what the statute means under ordinary principles of statutory interpretation, giving the agency's view appropriate respect but not binding weight. Steidinger is the first major appellate result: the Seventh Circuit declined to follow the FCC's position that texts count as calls for Do Not Call purposes.
It cuts both ways. FCC rulings that help defendants, such as safe harbors and favorable consent interpretations, are also open to challenge now, so a defense should not rest on an FCC order alone.
Insurance and vendor indemnity
Notify your insurers in writing as soon as you receive a TCPA demand or lawsuit, and send a written demand for defense and indemnity to any SMS platform, agency, or lead vendor whose contract may cover the claim.
Many commercial general liability policies contain exclusions for claims arising from the distribution of material in violation of the TCPA or similar laws, and some cyber or media policies address these claims differently. Coverage depends on the exact policy wording, and late notice can forfeit coverage that would otherwise exist, so tender first and argue about coverage later.
SMS platforms' terms usually make the sender responsible for compliance and often require the sender to indemnify the platform, not the other way around. Marketing agencies, affiliates, and lead or list vendors are a different story: if a third party collected the numbers or ran the campaign, its contract may require it to defend you or share the cost.
What to do this week
Preserve your consent and message records, stop texting the claimant, notify your insurer, and calendar every deadline in the letter or summons.
- Preserve platform data. Export the claimant's profile, opt-in record, message log with timestamps, and opt-out history from your SMS platform, and suspend any automatic deletion. Platforms don't keep everything forever.
- Save the sign-up form. Capture the current and past versions of the pop-up, checkout checkbox, or keyword flow, including the disclosure text, and any changes made by an agency.
- Stop texting the claimant. Add the number to your suppression list. Do not reach out to the claimant directly; if they have a lawyer, communications go through counsel.
- Don't ignore deadlines. A demand letter's response date is often followed by a lawsuit, and once served in federal court you generally have 21 days to respond. A default judgment multiplies the problem.
- Notify your insurer and vendors in writing, and keep copies.
- Don't pay or sign anything yet. An individual settlement can be reasonable, but it should include a proper release, and the terms matter if a class claim is still possible.
The data that wins these cases can disappear. Start your free review now and you'll hear back promptly.
Contacting me does not create an attorney-client relationship. Until we've confirmed there's no conflict and agreed in writing to work together, please send only your business name and a short description of what you need, and don't include other confidential details.
How I handle TCPA text message claims
I defend businesses against TCPA and state telemarketing demand letters and lawsuits over text messages, starting with the consent records and platform data, and I fix the program so the same claim doesn't come back.
I review the demand or complaint, gather and analyze your opt-in and message records, assess class exposure and coverage, tender to insurers and vendors, and negotiate or litigate from there. I'm admitted in Illinois and in the U.S. District Courts for the Northern and Central Districts of Illinois and the Eastern District of Wisconsin. In federal courts outside Illinois, I work with local counsel or seek admission for the case (pro hac vice). Once the claim is handled, I can audit your program under my SMS marketing compliance service.
Related: E-commerce law · Federal civil litigation
Frequently asked questions
What should I do if I get a TCPA demand letter about text messages?
Note the response date, preserve the claimant's opt-in record and message history from your SMS platform, and stop texting that number. Notify your insurer in writing, and have the claim reviewed before you respond or pay anything.
Can I be sued for sending marketing texts to people who signed up?
You can be sued, but consent is the main defense. If your records show when and how the person opted in and what disclosure they saw, many claims end there. Problems arise when the sign-up record is missing, the disclosure was incomplete, or texts continued after an opt-out.
What is a quiet hours lawsuit?
It is a claim that a business sent marketing texts before 8 a.m. or after 9 p.m. in the recipient's local time, in violation of the FCC's calling-hours rule. At least one federal court has held the rule does not apply when the recipient consented to the texts, and the Seventh Circuit's 2026 ruling that texts are not "calls" under the provision these claims rely on may limit them further.
How much do TCPA text message claims settle for?
There is no reliable typical number. Value depends on the strength of your consent records, how many people received the same messages, whether the claim is individual or class-wide, which court and state law apply, and insurance. The opening demand is rarely where these claims end.
Does my insurance cover a TCPA lawsuit?
Sometimes. Many general liability policies exclude TCPA claims, but wording varies and some other policies may respond. Notify every carrier in writing right away, because late notice can cost you coverage.
Can my SMS platform or marketing agency be made to pay?
It depends on the contracts. SMS platforms usually put compliance responsibility on the sender, but agencies, affiliates, and lead vendors that collected numbers or ran campaigns may owe you defense or indemnity. Send written notice to each of them early.
What is the Florida Telephone Solicitation Act, and does it apply to my business outside Florida?
The FTSA is Florida's mini-TCPA. It covers marketing texts to Florida consumers and allows $500 per violation, up to triple if willful or knowing. It can apply to businesses located anywhere, but for text claims the recipient must first reply STOP and give the sender 15 days to stop before suing.
Can you defend me if the case was filed outside Illinois?
Yes, in many cases. TCPA claims are federal, and demand letters can be answered from anywhere. In federal courts outside Illinois, I work with local counsel or seek admission for the case (pro hac vice).
Attorney Advertising. General information, not legal advice. Contacting this office does not create an attorney-client relationship. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Responsible attorney: Jonathan M. Francis, 3525 West Peterson Avenue, Suite 604, Chicago, Illinois 60659.