Your website terms and conditions decide where a customer dispute is heard, whether a customer can bring a class action, and what your business owes when something goes wrong, but only if a court finds the customer actually agreed to them. I'm Jonathan Francis, a website terms and conditions lawyer based in Chicago. I draft and review terms of use and terms of sale for online stores, subscription brands, and apps that sell nationwide.
Most enforceability fights are not about the words in the terms. They are about the checkout or sign-up screen: how the link was labeled, where it sat, and what the customer clicked.
This page is general information, not legal advice about your situation.
Free, confidential review. Send me your site address and tell me what you sell. I'll tell you what I would change in your terms and checkout flow, and quote a flat fee before any work starts.
Contacting me does not create an attorney-client relationship. Until we've confirmed there's no conflict and agreed in writing to work together, please send only your business name and a short description of what you need, and don't include other confidential details.
What are website terms and conditions?
Website terms and conditions are the contract between an online business and the people who use its site or buy from it, setting the rules for use, purchases, disputes, and liability.
They go by many names (terms of use, terms of service, terms and conditions), and the label doesn't matter. What matters is that they are a contract, so ordinary contract rules apply: there has to be an offer, notice of the terms, and the customer's assent. No general federal or Illinois law requires every website to post terms. But without them, you have no arbitration agreement, no liability cap, no license terms for your content, and no say over which state's law and courts apply. And some laws, like the auto-renewal rules discussed below, require specific disclosures that belong in or next to your terms.
Terms of use vs. terms of sale
Terms of use govern anyone who visits or uses your site, while terms of sale govern the purchase itself, and keeping them as separate documents (or clearly separate sections) often makes both easier to enforce and maintain.
Terms of use
Apply to every visitor: acceptable use, account rules, your ownership of site content, a license for user reviews and uploads, disclaimers, and dispute terms.
Terms of sale
Apply to buyers: pricing and payment, shipping and risk of loss, returns and refunds, warranties and disclaimers, subscription and auto-renewal terms, and limits of liability for the product.
Separating them often makes sense for practical reasons. A visitor who only browses never clicks anything, so terms of use are harder to enforce against them. A buyer, on the other hand, can be asked to agree at checkout, which is where the strongest assent happens. Putting purchase terms in a document the buyer actively accepts, and keeping the visitor rules in their own document, lets each one be presented in the way most likely to hold up. It also lets you update shipping or return terms without re-papering everything else.
Will a court enforce your terms? Clickwrap vs. browsewrap
In federal courts in the Seventh Circuit, applying state contract law, online terms bind a customer only if the site gave reasonably conspicuous notice of the terms and the customer took an action that unambiguously showed agreement, which is why clickwrap and well-designed checkout notices hold up and bare browsewrap links usually do not.
- Clickwrap: the customer checks a box or clicks a button stating they agree to linked terms. Courts generally enforce these.
- Browsewrap: the terms sit behind a footer link and the site says use equals agreement. Courts usually refuse to enforce these against consumers who never saw them.
- Sign-in wrap and hybrids: a line near the button says "By placing your order, you agree to our Terms." These live in the middle, and the screen design decides the case.
The starting point in the Seventh Circuit is Sgouros v. TransUnion Corp., 817 F.3d 1029 (7th Cir. 2016). Applying Illinois law, the court refused to enforce an arbitration clause that sat on page 8 of an agreement shown in a small scrolling box, behind a link labeled only "Printable Version," next to an "I Accept" button that appeared to relate to a different authorization.
In Domer v. Menard, Inc., 116 F.4th 686 (7th Cir. 2024), applying Wisconsin law, the court went the other way and enforced a retailer's online terms of order even though the buyer never checked a box. It looked at five factors: how simple the screen was, how clear the disclosure was, the font size and color, where the hyperlink sat, and when the notice appeared relative to the purchase. Most recently, in Rose v. Mercedes-Benz USA, LLC, No. 24-1042 (7th Cir. Feb. 13, 2026), the court, applying Illinois law, compelled arbitration where subscribers were told about the terms when they activated the service, before they paid for it, and held that customers' statements that they did not recall getting that notice were not enough to create a factual dispute.
Other circuits apply the same basic test but can be stricter about design. In Berman v. Freedom Financial Network, LLC, 30 F.4th 849 (9th Cir. 2022), the Ninth Circuit refused to enforce terms shown in tiny gray text with links that didn't look like links. If you sell nationwide, design for the stricter courts.
What usually holds up: an unchecked box or a clear statement right next to the "Place order" or "Create account" button, a link labeled with the document's actual name, readable font and contrasting link color, and a saved record of which version each customer accepted and when.
Arbitration clauses and class action waivers
An arbitration clause with a class action waiver can keep customer disputes out of court and out of class actions, but only if customers validly agreed to it and the clause is drafted to manage the risk of mass arbitration.
The Federal Arbitration Act makes written arbitration agreements "valid, irrevocable, and enforceable" except on grounds that apply to contracts generally (9 U.S.C. § 2), and the Supreme Court has held that the Act protects class action waivers in consumer arbitration agreements (AT&T Mobility LLC v. Concepcion, 563 U.S. 333 (2011)).
The flip side is mass arbitration: plaintiffs' firms file hundreds or thousands of individual arbitration demands at once, and the business usually owes the arbitration provider's filing fees for each one. In Wallrich v. Samsung Electronics America, Inc., 106 F.4th 609 (7th Cir. 2024), more than 35,000 consumers filed demands and the business was billed about $4.1 million in initial filing fees. A clause written years ago with no thought to this can turn a class action waiver into a larger bill than the class action. Terms I draft typically address:
- Carve-outs for small claims court and for injunctions over intellectual property, so you can still go to court to stop counterfeiting or misuse of your content.
- Which provider and which rules apply, including the provider's mass-arbitration procedures and fee schedule.
- Batching or bellwether provisions for large numbers of similar claims, and an informal pre-dispute notice period.
- Delegation and severability, so a court knows who decides disputes about the clause and what happens if part of it fails.
The other clauses that do the work
Beyond arbitration, the clauses that most often matter in a real dispute are the limitation of liability, intellectual property and content terms, governing law and venue, and the clause that controls how you change the terms.
Limitation of liability and disclaimers
A cap on damages and a disclaimer of implied warranties can limit exposure, but they must be conspicuous, and some consumer laws won't allow them to be waived. A cap that tries to exclude everything is more likely to be thrown out entirely.
Intellectual property and user content
Your terms should say you own the site's photos, copy, and design; grant users only a limited license; and take a license to reviews, photos, and other content customers submit so you can use it in marketing. If you host user uploads, add a copyright takedown procedure.
Governing law and venue
Choosing Illinois law and a Cook County or Northern District of Illinois forum means disputes that stay in court come to you. Courts usually enforce these clauses in business terms, but some state consumer laws limit them.
Changes to the terms
A clause saying "we may change these terms at any time, and continued use means you agree" is weak on its own, because the customer may never see the new version. Changes should apply going forward, material changes (especially to arbitration) should come with notice and a fresh agreement at the next login or purchase, and you should keep dated copies of every version.
Auto-renewal and subscription terms
If you sell subscriptions, memberships, or auto-renewing plans, federal and state law require clear disclosure of the renewal terms before you take payment, the customer's affirmative consent, and an easy way to cancel, and the federal "click-to-cancel" rule is not in effect.
- Federal law (ROSCA). For online sales with a negative option, the Restore Online Shoppers' Confidence Act requires clear disclosure of all material terms before collecting billing information, express informed consent before charging, and simple mechanisms to stop recurring charges (15 U.S.C. § 8403). It is in force and the FTC enforces it.
- The FTC "click-to-cancel" rule. The FTC's 2024 amended Negative Option Rule was vacated in full by the Eighth Circuit on July 8, 2025, days before most of it would have taken effect (Custom Communications, Inc. v. FTC, 142 F.4th 1060 (8th Cir. 2025)). The FTC restarted the process with an advance notice of proposed rulemaking in March 2026 (FTC rule page). As of October 2026, no new proposed rule has been published, so the click-to-cancel provisions impose no current obligations. The FTC's older rule for prenotification plans (16 C.F.R. Part 425) still applies to those plans.
- Illinois Automatic Contract Renewal Act. Illinois requires clear disclosure of renewal terms next to the consent request, consent before charging, and an acknowledgment the customer can keep (815 ILCS 601/10). It also requires written notice 30 to 60 days before the cancellation deadline for contracts of 12 months or more, and since January 1, 2022 (Public Act 102-517), businesses that sign customers up online must let them cancel online. Since January 1, 2025 (Public Act 103-919), free trials or promotional periods of 15 days or longer require a reminder at least 3 days before the customer must cancel to avoid being charged.
- California Automatic Renewal Law. California's law (Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code § 17602) was amended effective July 1, 2025 to require express affirmative consent to the renewal terms, annual reminders, a prominent online cancellation option for customers who signed up online, and retention of consent records. Many national brands build their subscription flow to California's rules because they are among the strictest.
Subscription terms have to match what actually happens in your checkout and billing system. A clean terms document cannot fix a cancellation flow that takes six clicks and a phone call.
Why copied templates fail
Template and copied terms fail because they describe a generic business instead of yours, and the gaps tend to surface at the moment you need the terms to work.
- They promise return windows, shipping practices, or data handling your store doesn't actually follow, which can itself become a deceptive-practices claim.
- They are copied from a competitor, which can infringe the competitor's copyright and often carries over the competitor's company name, state, or forum.
- They include an arbitration clause with no thought to mass-arbitration fees, or none at all.
- They omit the auto-renewal disclosures your subscription program requires.
- They are posted only as a footer link, so the strongest version of the document is presented in the weakest way.
- Platform templates, including the default Shopify policy generators, are a reasonable start but are not tailored to your products, state, or risk.
Your terms should also match your privacy policy; conflicts between the two are a common problem in demand letters.
Not sure your terms would hold up? Start your free review. I'll look at your checkout and sign-up screens, not just the document.
Contacting me does not create an attorney-client relationship. Until we've confirmed there's no conflict and agreed in writing to work together, please send only your business name and a short description of what you need, and don't include other confidential details.
How I work as your website terms and conditions lawyer
As a website terms and conditions lawyer, I review how your site actually presents its terms, draft terms of use and terms of sale that match how your business operates, and work with you or your developer on the assent flow so the terms are enforceable.
- Review. I walk through your site as a customer: account sign-up, checkout, subscription enrollment, and cancellation. I compare what the screens say to what your current terms say.
- Prioritized fix list and flat fee. You get a short list ranked by risk and a flat-fee quote for the work.
- Drafting. Terms of use and terms of sale written for your products, policies, and dispute strategy, including arbitration choices you understand.
- Assent design. Specific wording and placement for checkboxes and button-adjacent notices, plus a plan for keeping dated versions and acceptance records.
- Updates. When the law or your business changes, I update the terms and the notice process for existing customers.
If a customer dispute or class action is already underway, I defend businesses in Illinois state court and federal court. In federal courts outside Illinois, I work with local counsel or seek admission for the case (pro hac vice).
Related: E-commerce legal checklist · Data privacy compliance · Business and IP litigation
Frequently asked questions
Do I need terms and conditions on my website?
No general law requires every website to post terms, but an online store without them has no arbitration agreement, no limit of liability, no return or refund rules customers agreed to, and no choice of law or court. If you sell subscriptions, state and federal auto-renewal laws require specific disclosures anyway.
What is the difference between clickwrap and browsewrap?
Clickwrap requires the customer to check a box or click a button agreeing to linked terms, and courts generally enforce it. Browsewrap just posts a link and says that using the site means agreement, and courts usually won't enforce it against consumers who never saw the terms. Many checkouts fall in between, and the screen design decides those cases.
Can my website terms include an arbitration clause and a class action waiver?
Yes. The Federal Arbitration Act generally enforces arbitration agreements, including class action waivers, if the customer validly agreed. The clause should be drafted with mass arbitration in mind, because individual filing fees across thousands of claims can exceed the cost of a class action.
Do I need separate terms of sale for my online store?
Not always, but it often makes sense. Purchase terms like returns, shipping, warranties, and auto-renewal can be accepted at checkout, which is the strongest form of assent, while general site-use rules apply to every visitor. Separate documents, or clearly separate sections, make each easier to present and update.
Is the Shopify terms and conditions template good enough?
It is a starting point. A generator doesn't know your return practices, subscription terms, data sharing, or dispute strategy, and it won't fix how the terms are presented at checkout, which is usually where enforceability is won or lost.
Can I change my terms and conditions at any time?
You can update them, but a change isn't automatically binding on existing customers just because you posted it. Material changes, especially to arbitration, should apply going forward and come with notice and a fresh agreement at the next login or purchase, and you should keep dated copies of each version.
Is the FTC click-to-cancel rule in effect?
No. The Eighth Circuit vacated the FTC's amended Negative Option Rule in July 2025, and the FTC's restarted rulemaking had not produced a proposed rule as of October 2026. The federal ROSCA statute and state laws in Illinois, California, and elsewhere still require clear disclosures, consent, and easy cancellation.
Does the Illinois auto-renewal law apply to my business if I'm not in Illinois?
It can, because it protects consumers in Illinois who sign up for automatically renewing contracts. If you sell subscriptions nationwide, your flow should satisfy Illinois and California at a minimum.
Attorney Advertising. General information, not legal advice. Contacting this office does not create an attorney-client relationship. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Responsible attorney: Jonathan M. Francis, 3525 West Peterson Avenue, Suite 604, Chicago, Illinois 60659.